top of page
Search

Why Many Staten Island Homebuyers Are Choosing New Jersey

  • Writer: Stephanie Orefice
    Stephanie Orefice
  • Feb 20
  • 2 min read

Many Staten Island families start their home search hoping to stay close to home. They love their community, schools, and familiar neighborhoods—but often, reality hits when they begin comparing options.

Detached homes are limited in Staten Island, and prices can be high for the space buyers want. That’s when New Jersey enters the picture as a smart alternative: more space, larger yards, and often better value—all within commuting distance.


As a licensed NY & NJ agent, I’ve seen this pattern hundreds of times. Let’s explore why NJ is becoming the top choice for Staten Island homebuyers.



1. Staten Island vs. New Jersey: The Space Factor

  • Many Staten Island homes in the $500,000-$700,000 are townhouses or attached homes, with limited backyard space.

  • New Jersey offers more detached homes with bigger yards, ideal for families and pets.

  • Extra space translates into more comfort for kids, home offices, and entertaining.

For many buyers, seeing a detached NJ home with a backyard is an eye-opener. It’s often the tipping point in choosing NJ over staying in Staten Island.

2. Better Value in New Jersey

  • NJ homes often offer larger square footage at lower price per square foot.

  • Buyers can get more bedrooms, larger lots, and modern layouts without stretching their budget.

  • Even factoring in commuting costs, NJ can provide a better lifestyle and financial value.


3. Close Enough for Commuting

  • Many NJ towns near Staten Island—like Howell, Marlboro, Old Bridge, and Freehold—are within an hour’s drive or public transit options.

  • Families can enjoy NJ space while still staying connected to work, school, and Staten Island friends.


4. Lifestyle & Amenities

  • NJ towns often have parks, recreation centers, and family-friendly communities.

  • Shopping, dining, and entertainment options are plentiful without the NYC price tag.

  • Safe, suburban neighborhoods make it easier for families to plan long-term.


5. How a Dual-Licensed Agent Helps

  • Buyers exploring both Staten Island and NJ options benefit from an agent licensed in both Staten Island & New Jersey.

  • I can:

    • Show properties on both sides of the bridge

    • Compare taxes and monthly costs

    • Help families make an informed choice between staying in Staten Island or moving to New Jersey


Many Staten Island buyers start the search hoping to stay local, but when they see what New Jersey has to offer—more space, detached homes, and better value—their priorities shift.

If you’re exploring options on either side of the bridge, it’s important to see the full picture before deciding.



➡ Try the Net Proceeds Calculator to compare budgets and costs

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page